Sugar Pie Suite

Caroline Street 537, Downtown Key West, Key West, United States of America - Close to attractions
6.0/10 · 1 review

Offering an aqua park and a golf course, the comfortable Sugar Pie Suite Key West hotel is located in the Downtown Key West district, about a 5-minute walk from the performing arts theater "Red Barn Theatre".

Location

The inn is located 0.4 miles from the bustling plaza "Mallory Square", and 1.1 miles from Southernmost Point of the Continental US Monument. Within a few blocks of this Key West hotel, The Ernest Hemingway Home and Museum is located. The Sugar Pie Suite is also within 20 minutes' walk of Key West Butterfly and Nature Conservatory. The accommodation is right near Caroline Street & Simonton Street bus station. This hotel lies within a 10-minute drive of Key West International airport.

Rooms

The rooms provide ironing facilities and an air conditioner, along with coffee and tea makers for guests' comfort. Also, guests can overlook the city from some rooms.

Food & Drinks

Irish Kevin's Bar is right around the corner from the Sugar Pie Suite Key West.

Leisure & Activities

Activities include cycling and fishing.

Why choose Sugar Pie Suite Key West

Select room

  • Air-conditioned rooms with patios

  • Outdoor swimming pool available

  • Free Wi-Fi throughout property

  • Cycling and fishing activities offered

Main amenities

  • Free Wi-Fi

  • Swimming Pool

  • Sports activities

  • Air conditioning

  • Pets

General
  • Free Wi-Fi
  • Swimming Pool
  • Sports activities
  • Air conditioning
  • Pets
1/3

Internet

  • Free Wi-Fi in public areas

Parking options

  • Parking

Activities

  • Water sports
  • Cycling
  • Golf course
  • Fishing

Recreation

  • Outdoor swimming pool
  • Aqua park
  • Garden area
  • BBQ facilities

In the rooms

  • Air conditioning
  • Mini-bar
  • Patio
  • Garden furniture
  • Tea and coffee facilities

In the bathroom

  • Free toiletries

Devices

  • Flat-screen TV

General facilities

  • No smoking on site
  • Smoke detectors

Pets

  • Pets allowed

Important information

Check-in:
from 16:00 until 23:59
Check-out:
until 10:00

Enter dates to see availability

From USD 297 per night
Check-in 21 Oct 2026
Check-out 22 Oct 2026
Guests 2 guests

Adults:

2

Children:

0
All rates verified
How we verified prices Our team regularly checks prices to make sure you see the lowest available rates. We compare them with hotel prices and other providers. If discounts or promotions appear, prices on our site are updated accordingly.

Rooms

Current offers Editor's Pick
Up to 20% off

Early Bird

Reserve while the right dates are open, then enjoy planning everything that comes after stress-free, step by step.
Book 30+ days ahead Some dates already include an extra discount
Up to 15% off

Longer Stays

A few extra nights let you slow down, find favorite spots, and experience the place beyond the highlights.
5 nights or more Discount will be applied to your results
Up to 10% off

Mobile Rates

Book in a few taps and save a little more for the places, tastes, and moments waiting throughout your stay.
Book via mobile Includes special rates from Booking.com

Photos of Sugar Pie Suite Key West

Sugar Pie Suite 1/8
Sugar Pie Suite
Sugar Pie Suite
Sugar Pie Suite
Sugar Pie Suite

Sugar Pie Suite Key West

Hotel with air-conditioned rooms and outdoor pool

Gallery

Sugar Pie Suite

Sugar Pie * Key West
Sugar Pie *
Sugar Pie Key West
Sugar Pie * Key West
Sugar Pie *
Sugar Pie Key West
Sugar Pie Inn
Inn Sugar Pie

Best options for your travel dates

Location of Sugar Pie Suite Key West

Caroline Street 537, Downtown Key West, Key West, United States of America

 -  Close to attractions
Attractions
Great restaurants
Transportation

Places nearby

    Guest reviews of Sugar Pie Suite Key West

    Based on ratings from trusted providers

    6.0 /10
    Pleasant 1 review
    Filter Reviews
    Based on ratings from trusted providers
    Traveler Type
      Languages
        Review scores
          Solo Couple Family Extended group Leisure Business Wonderful: 9+ Good: 7-9 Fair: 5-7 Poor: 3-5 Very poor: 1-3
          ...

          Write a review

          When did you travel?

          Your rating point

          Very bad
          Excellent

          Your details

          Where are you from?
          Thank you! Thank you for taking the time to share your experience. Your review will be published shortly.

          Review has not been sent.

          Please try again.

          Currency
          • USD U.S. dollar
          • EUR Euro
          • GBP Pound sterling
          • AUD Australian dollar
          • CAD Canadian dollar
          • BRL Brazilian real
          • CNY Chinese yuan
          • CZK Czech koruna
          • DKK Danish krone
          • HKD Hong Kong dollar
          • ILS Gaza Strip, Israel New Shekel
          • JPY Japanese yen
          • MYR Malaysian Ringgit
          • NZD New Zealand dollar
          • NOK Norwegian krone
          • PLN Polish zloty
          • RON Romanian new leu
          • RUB Russian ruble
          • SAR Saudi riyal
          • SGD Singapore dollar
          • ZAR South African rand
          • KRW South Korean won
          • SEK Swedish krona
          • CHF Swiss franc
          • TRY Turkish lira
          • UAH Ukrainian hryvnia
          • THB Thai Baht
          • ARS Argentina, Peso
          Select language
          • us
            us English
          • en
            en English
          100% Verified Reviews
          Enter dates to see availability
          From USD 297 per night
          Check-in 21 Oct 2026
          Check-out 22 Oct 2026
          Guests 2 guests

          Adults:

          2

          Children:

          0
          All rates verified
          How we verified prices Our team regularly checks prices to make sure you see the lowest available rates. We compare them with hotel prices and other providers. If discounts or promotions appear, prices on our site are updated accordingly.
          Check-in & out
          21 Oct 2026
          —
          22 Oct 2026
          Guests
          2 guests
          Check availability
          We're here to help
          Hi there! Have a question? Message us—our team is happy to assist.
          Your details:
          Subject:
          Message:
          Thank you for your message. We’ll get back to you shortly!
          Your message was not delivered
          Important information
          Sugar Pie Suite
          Check-in:
          from 16:00 until 23:59
          Check-out:
          until 10:00